Get the latest updates from our LinkedIn page! https://onelink.to/treesandlines
Welcome back to another episode of the Trees & Lines podcast. Liz Westberg, Business Development at Growth Solutions, joins us to discuss how tree growth regulators are helping utilities reduce long-term vegetation management costs by slowing regrowth and extending pruning cycles. Liz breaks down the science behind paclobutrazol, explaining how it works at the cellular level by reducing gibberellic acid production and redirecting tree energy in ways that also improve drought tolerance, root development, and overall tree health. She walks through the business case for TGRs, including cost savings of 20 to 70% depending on access conditions, and explains why timing treatments close to pruning events is critical to getting the best results out of any program.
The conversation also covers species considerations across deciduous trees, conifers, and monocots, why implementation scope and target selection matter more than most utilities realize, and how Growth Solutions manages landowner communication and opt-out programs in the field. Liz shares why less than 20% of utilities currently use TGRs despite decades of availability, what it takes to build the internal business case for adoption, and why the foresters who have implemented these programs rarely want to give them up once they start seeing results. Have a listen, hope you enjoy!
Transcription:
00:00:00:02 – 00:00:30:16
Phil
Welcome to the trees and Lines podcast, where we discuss fresh perspectives on utility vegetation management with your host Phil and tej. Don’t forget to follow along on LinkedIn for the latest news. Now let’s dive into this week’s episode. Welcome to the Trees and Lines podcast. Today I’m going to be joined by Brian Sprinkle as my co-host, and we are welcoming Liz Westberg, who is the self-identified tree nerd from Growth Solutions.
00:00:30:18 – 00:00:32:12
Phil
Welcome, Liz.
00:00:32:14 – 00:00:34:06
Liz
Well, hey, I’m glad to be here.
00:00:34:09 – 00:00:40:11
Phil
Yeah. Appreciate your joining us. Hey, Liz, why don’t we start off by you telling us a little bit about yourself and growth solutions?
00:00:40:13 – 00:01:02:17
Liz
Absolutely. All right, so, technically, my job title is Business development with Growth Solutions. Self-identified tree nerd. Absolutely. That’s what I prefer to go with most days. So Growth Solutions is a tree growth regulator applicator company. I have been with the company now for oof seven going on eight years here. I think sometime in the next few months.
00:01:02:19 – 00:01:23:04
Liz
And my background is actually not even in trees. Originally I was a wildlife major, from University of Wisconsin, Stevens Point. But like a lot of people, I kind of I ended up in tree care, and I ended up being lured into the utility arborist world, with the promise of travel and adventure. And both of those things have turned out to be true.
00:01:23:06 – 00:01:46:09
Liz
So I got into working with tree growth regulators, because Growth Solutions is owned by a company called Rainbow Companies. And, we make that product as well as do the applications. And I’ve really, really enjoyed being a part of something in the utility arborist world that is working to save or preserve trees, in the utility, forest and the urban forest, really.
00:01:46:09 – 00:01:49:03
Liz
And that’s been something that’s been a big draw for me and kept me going.
00:01:49:05 – 00:02:12:23
Phil
Yeah. Well, good. You know, Liz, tree growth regulators have been around for a long time. I once came across the Utility Arborist Association’s very first newsletter from 70. Oh, wow. And the subject matter was tree growth regulators. Tree growth regulators were a little different back then. So yeah. Tell us a little bit about the evolution of this and then where we are today.
00:02:13:01 – 00:02:34:05
Liz
Tree growth regulators have really been investigated since going back all the way to the 50s. So first newsletter in the 70s is pretty cool. But they started looking into, different chemicals that would help slow the growth of trees way back in the 50s. And some of those older ones, had varying and interesting results for the health of the tree.
00:02:34:07 – 00:03:04:23
Liz
In a lot of different, a lot of different methods for application, they were using spray on things. They were using trunk injections. They tried all sorts of fun stuff. The older ones that we would typically call those type one TGRs or type one tree growth regulators. And they work typically by stopping cell division, entirely, where they’re applied and what that means for the tree is mixed results for, for its health, which can cause further problems down the line, both for, for the owner of that tree and even the utilities.
00:03:04:23 – 00:03:25:15
Liz
But you got now a dead tree in the in the right away. It was in, it was in the 80s and 90s, really, that they started experimenting for as growth regulators with these type two TGRs that we use more commonly today. So by far the most common active ingredient is Paclobutrazol and that was that’s also been around since the 40s.
00:03:25:15 – 00:03:47:21
Liz
But they originally looked at that one as a fungicide. Doesn’t work really well as a fungicide at all. But they noticed as they were studying it that it did have these growth regulation or growth regulation properties. They were using those as trunk injections. And again, kind of mixed results. If you’ve been around for a while, you probably remember there’s they’re really hard to get predictable results when doing trunk injections.
00:03:47:21 – 00:04:01:07
Liz
And they were also doing some damage to the bark of the tree because they had to be suspended, typically in an alcohol. So you can do maybe one injection and get away with it. But if you’re trying to do it over and over again every few years, you’re going to run into issues for the health of that tree.
00:04:01:09 – 00:04:25:11
Liz
Fast forward a few more years. In the late 90s and early 2000, they finally got a formulation that was a soil, soil treatment. So either as a basal drench or as a soil injection with a probe. And from there, we’re really seeing a lot better results, both in terms of the health of the tree and in terms of being able to to narrow down those rates and get really good, predictable results for regulating the growth.
00:04:25:11 – 00:04:36:13
Liz
So way different than than what you might have seen a few decades ago, even in even the last ten, ten, 15 years. We’ve come a long way in how we actually do the applications.
00:04:36:15 – 00:04:52:18
Brian
I think tree growth regulators is a fascinating realm within the utility space. So I was going to ask you a little bit about the economics and market space behind tree growth regulators. Sure. Just tell me a little bit about the adoption, overall within the market. And we’ll just focus on the US market because I know that’s where you’re primarily focused.
00:04:52:20 – 00:05:02:16
Brian
Like, tell me about the adoption, the economics behind why it makes sense where the applications are primarily being done now. What target trees. Just a little bit more information on the business case behind it.
00:05:02:19 – 00:05:22:21
Liz
Oh, man. There’s a there’s a lot of questions in there. We can break that apart bit by bit. So in business case, at its real heart, what we’re looking at doing is helping utilities control their pruning costs in the future. So using tree growth regulators is going to slow down the regrowth of that tree 40 to 70%, depending on the species.
00:05:22:21 – 00:05:48:03
Liz
It’s going to vary. Thus extending out the amount of time between pruning events on a given tree. So it’s been kind of used in a lot of different ways. But the primary use is going to be distribution lines, where you don’t have, you know, the requirements to maintain really large corridors and high clearance. And where you also have a lot more, a lot more landowners and property owners who want to keep the trees on that property.
00:05:48:05 – 00:06:05:17
Liz
So distribution lines as well as, some of the lower voltage, some transmission lines or where we see it used most frequently, typically in developed areas. So it’s not going to be a big economic benefit to use trigger with regulators in areas where you can get, you know, draft saws in there and do mechanical, heavy mechanical pruning and things like that.
00:06:05:21 – 00:06:24:16
Liz
But anywhere you have to have a bucket, crews and especially climbers, you’re going to see huge benefits because just the pruning costs and the labor associated with those are much, much higher. So in terms of the actual benefits or been a couple studies, it’s hard it’s hard to track records when budgets are so inconsistent from year to year utilities as it is.
00:06:24:18 – 00:06:45:21
Liz
But some of the ones where they have looked at it. Yeah, you can see savings over the course of three, 3 or 4 years as as little as maybe 20 to 40% for some of those front yard bucket prune areas much higher, you know, 70 plus percent for for backlot or difficult or sensitive areas that you have to have a climbing crew to access.
00:06:45:23 – 00:07:14:00
Liz
So that’s in a nutshell. Probably the economics of it. It can we can get a lot more specific with with other benefits we see. I have a lot of utilities who use this talk about an improvement in their Sadie’s safety scores are all the reliability metrics. So that helps them save in the long run. A lot of a lot of those, cost control methods or measures come from a reduction in any reactive or mid-cycle work that they have to do throughout the years.
00:07:14:02 – 00:07:29:19
Liz
And even when they do have to come back and prune the trees, they’ve grown a lot less. So there’s a lot less brush to move. They can move a bit more efficiently as a, as they’re going through their, their circuit again and hauling away all that, all that debris. So, so many different ways. Those are some of the basic ones.
00:07:29:21 – 00:07:32:00
Liz
Any more specifics you want dive into?
00:07:32:02 – 00:07:51:00
Brian
You know, I appreciate you covered. A follow up to that would be timing, right? Yeah. Can you give us a little bit about the application method? Because I think that, you know, that’s a operationally speaking, how do we how does utilities integrate this into their existing processes to be to be, efficient and effective at the application process?
00:07:51:02 – 00:08:09:22
Liz
Absolutely. And, you know, that is a huge topic. And I, I do I do a fair amount of speaking out at, other conferences. And I do feel a few different topics. One of the talks I’m developing right now, my working title for it is Why TGRs Fail. Right. Kind of where we’re going for the kind of the clickbait method there, right?
00:08:09:22 – 00:08:34:03
Liz
You’d be shocked. And in a nutshell, it comes down to implementation. And I think that’s one of the biggest areas where utilities that have implemented TGR programs and not seeing the results they want. It comes down to having not developed a good scope, right. What trees they do and don’t want to target. It comes down to maybe not selecting the best areas to target tigers.
00:08:34:05 – 00:08:51:14
Liz
You know, trying to either do a blanket approach, which can work. And absolutely. We do have utility partners who try and get every single tree they can. But with a limited budget, obviously you’re not going to see as good a result as if you’re doing a more targeted approach. And then, as you mentioned, timing and timing is a big one.
00:08:51:14 – 00:08:56:14
Liz
So the product itself works. And we want to delve into a little bit of a science lesson as we’re working into this one.
00:08:56:16 – 00:08:57:15
Brian
Absolutely.
00:08:57:17 – 00:09:22:21
Liz
Perfect. All right. So like I said, tree and here I love talking about this stuff. How it works in the tree itself is we are going to be reducing the production of a hormone called gibberellic acid. And what to gibberellic are responsible for, among other things, is cellular elongation. So imagine you’ve got these trees and, they don’t know that they’re planted in someone’s front yard under a power line.
00:09:22:23 – 00:09:49:14
Liz
As far as the tree is concerned, it’s in a forest. It’s surrounded by other trees and it, it’s primary resource limiter in a forest is actually going to be sunlight, right? It’s not water, it’s not nutrients. It’s sunlight. And so it’s in the tree’s best interest to re sprout as fast as possible when it loses its canopy and get back into that canopy space so it doesn’t lose out, lose out on possible sunlight from competition from other trees.
00:09:49:16 – 00:10:08:19
Liz
And how it does this isn’t necessarily by growing faster, it’s by stretching out its branches. I know that’s a distinction without a difference, but the cells don’t divide faster. They stretch out kind of like if they get pulled thinner, like Laffy Taffy. That’s why those branches look so straight and spindly. Yeah. And the wood itself is typically weaker.
00:10:08:19 – 00:10:28:03
Liz
There’s a lot of sprouts. So the branch unions are really weak, but the tree doesn’t care because it’s just trying to regain that lost canopy space. So what paclobutrazol does is it gets in there and it blocks a step in the metabolic pathway that produces gibberelliians It’s kind of like throwing a wrench into the cogs of an assembly line.
00:10:28:05 – 00:10:50:08
Liz
And all that energy goes somewhere else. And we can talk about that too, if you like, and why? It’s a beneficial process for the trees, but by blocking the blocking the gibberellian, we are preventing, that rapid regrowth because the stretching out of those branches. So how this relates to timing, the process of producing those gibberellian really kicks in at the time of pruning.
00:10:50:10 – 00:11:16:01
Liz
The tree loses as part of that canopy and it goes, oh no, oh no, I need to regrow as fast as possible. And it starts producing those two problems at a higher rate. So you want to treat the tree within a window of pruning to really maximize on the reduction of those gibberellians and the label says 60 days before or after pruning, the closer to that pruning date you can get, or even, you know, a couple of weeks before would be my perfect time window, the more control you’re going to get on that process.
00:11:16:03 – 00:11:39:01
Liz
So the challenge then for the manager is timing your pruning curves and your TGR application curves to be out there around the same time. And since TGRs are much faster process than pruning as you can imagine, a single TGR applicator could probably be working alongside, you know, 3 or 4 plus or more pruners on the circuit at the same time.
00:11:39:03 – 00:11:58:01
Liz
Yeah, so, so planning that work for the throughout the year, can be a little challenging. I’ve seen some creative and awesome ways of dealing with it. One of my favorite methods that I’ve heard of is, Forester uses likes to leave his his worst performing circuits for the end of the year. And then have us come out there.
00:11:58:03 – 00:12:08:04
Liz
There, there are farther southern states or carve outs that come out there in the winter, and do them at the same time to make sure he gets that timing right on those particularly troublesome circuits.
00:12:08:06 – 00:12:09:16
Brian
Thats interesting information.
00:12:09:18 – 00:12:14:11
Phil
Yeah. So tell us, where does it go if it’s not in or the gibberellian
00:12:14:11 – 00:12:14:22
Liz
Yeah.
00:12:14:23 – 00:12:17:06
Phil
If not into elongation
00:12:17:08 – 00:12:37:07
Liz
Absolutely. So that energy like I it has to go somewhere. And this is why and where it goes is into production primarily of a different hormone called abscisic acid. All right. We’re going to I don’t know if there’s cues associated with this podcast, but I’d be making your earn them today. abscisic acid is often called the Stress hormone.
00:12:37:09 – 00:13:00:08
Liz
Sometimes I’ve heard it called the protection hormone. It’s what the tree produces when it thinks it’s under stress, primarily through something like drought. Occasionally in insect infestation, things like that. But drought. Well, one of the more common culprits for, for, initiating abscisic acid production. So what that does to the tree is it encourages it to produce more fibrous roots.
00:13:00:08 – 00:13:16:07
Liz
Right? So not the big structural roots that are going to push up your sidewalk, but the tiny hairlike ones that are going to take up water and nutrients, it’s also going to encourage the tree to have a thicker, waxy or cuticle that’s that kind of the the waxy layer on the outside of a leaf. So it’s going to lose less water.
00:13:16:07 – 00:13:37:05
Liz
You’re going to see less, sun scorch on those leaves and it’s going to encourage the stomata or the gas exchange pores on the bottom of the leaf to stay closed a bit more often than they would otherwise, again, preventing water loss and preventing some of the worst effects from drought. So what we see with the use of backlit beaches, all is trees that are a lot more drought tolerant.
00:13:37:07 – 00:13:51:22
Liz
And if you’re in an area where there is no drought, even better. The tree doesn’t know there’s a drought or not. It’s still going to have those responses, and it’s just going to end up with much, much, much greener leaves. And, you know, kind of a tighter canopy in that regard. Sometimes the leaves are a little small, too.
00:13:52:03 – 00:14:23:09
Liz
We will see that in some species where, you know, maples in particular, they’ll, they’ll end up with little leaves, which can look kind of fun. But by and large, that’s just a that is cosmetics. And the tree itself is generally happier. In fact, outside of the utility world, these same products, paclobutrazol based ones are used super commonly by, you know, commercial arborists for trees that are drought distressed or for trees that, larger ones that have been transplanted, you know, four inches in diameter or greater, or trees that are having other issues.
00:14:23:11 – 00:14:33:10
Liz
What I like to say always is it doesn’t it doesn’t cure any diseases or any issues with trees. But it’s a great to follow up as a as something to help it recover from those stressful incidents.
00:14:33:12 – 00:14:35:01
Phil
Gives the tree a fighting chance.
00:14:35:01 – 00:14:41:10
Liz
Absolutely right. It’s like the cough medicine you take, but you also still need the penicillin to treat the disease or whatever you’re dealing with it.
00:14:41:12 – 00:15:05:04
Brian
Yeah, on that topic. And I you know, I did a pilot program out West in my previous life. At the big topic I was exploring at that point in time was not only treating yard trees and ornamentals, etc. people that, you know, the people, trees that people cared about the most. But another component to this was orchard related trees, fruit production trees for food and consumption.
00:15:05:06 – 00:15:27:09
Brian
And I know that at that point in time there was some discussions about because and you’re in Europe and various other, first world countries, parts of the, you know, the, the world, they do this, they utilize free growth regulator to on on fruit production. And can you tell me where we’re at with that? You know, the states ensure approval process because that’s a it’s a it’s a big challenge out west and especially California.
00:15:27:09 – 00:15:30:05
Brian
We’re absolutely the breadbasket of the world you know.
00:15:30:05 – 00:15:49:23
Liz
So yep. And I and you know even and I I’m familiar with the project you’re referring to as well it’s it’s one that we’ve done some work on and even outside just power lines that go over orchards. Right. Just like the, the use this product could have on fruit production. So, it would actually be pretty great if we were able to use paclitaxel.
00:15:50:01 – 00:16:13:23
Liz
On more on industrial agriculture scale in the US at the moment, we cannot one of the things you’re going to see and why it is used in other countries, is it, the reduction of those that that branch growth, it doesn’t reduce the number of buds that are produced. It doesn’t reduce the number of flowers are produced in fact, a lot of species that, just a gas, it is going to encourage more flowering and you end up with a higher, you know, fruit per stem count.
00:16:14:00 – 00:16:34:20
Liz
And it’s something that gets used heavily in you mentioned Europe. I know of it being used at like almond groves in Mexico because they can get more, more, more nuts per stem with the trees. And that’s obviously a really, really big deal. What it comes down to is, is simply economics at this point and and in particular government regulation.
00:16:34:22 – 00:16:58:05
Liz
So when, when it was something that we were looking into, or at least the parent company, I, I wasn’t involved in that project. It is not a quick or easy or cheap process to get FDA approval for a chemical pesticide use, and that is always regulated by the EPA, is regulated as a pesticide, even though it doesn’t harm most species.
00:16:58:07 – 00:17:23:20
Liz
It’s not easy to get that approved for for agricultural use. So yeah, what any company that wants to do that is looking at is probably minimum half a million or more or several hundred, 700 mil, excuse me, several hundred thousand dollars per species to get that label approval to be used. For, for agricultural purposes. The second challenge then is, is the labor to it.
00:17:23:22 – 00:17:48:03
Liz
At this point in time, you can’t do PAC flow in a drip line. So it has to be applied per tree on a per tree basis. So it’s pretty, pretty labor intensive as well. Again, I know they do this in other countries. My my favorite saying is if you’ve eaten an almond, chances are it came from Mexico. And if it came from Mexico, chances are they used pac lo at some point or other in that in that tree’s life.
00:17:48:03 – 00:18:00:09
Liz
So it’s not a question of, of human consumption safety. It’s just about the logistics of, of getting it through the approval process with the FDA. For use and AG purposes.
00:18:00:11 – 00:18:01:12
Brian
And understandably so.
00:18:01:14 – 00:18:16:20
Liz
It’s not something that we’re pursuing on a large scale. I know there there was a research trial that would have allowed us to do just I think it was just almonds and just under the power lines and nothing else. But, that’s as far as that one ever got.
00:18:16:22 – 00:18:22:00
Brian
Interesting. Yeah. Hopefully we start to see more exploration. Exploration in that adoption theory.
00:18:22:00 – 00:18:29:04
Phil
The talk to us a little bit about the industry’s adoption. And they’ve been at it for decades. Where where do we stand?
00:18:29:06 – 00:18:45:23
Liz
Where do we stand? That’s a good one. So I think, back when, back when they were called, can you see it’s using now? Right. They actually did a study a few years back in 2019. Don’t quote me on that. Where they were surveying, managers on a lot of, a lot of different tree. Tree?
00:18:45:23 – 00:18:51:12
Liz
Really? The benchmark. Exactly right. The benchmark one know you probably know better than I do. But I do know that.
00:18:51:14 – 00:18:54:18
Brian
Way back in my life.
00:18:54:20 – 00:19:17:12
Liz
They had a few questions in there about tigers and, not a very large percentage of utilities said that they used them. It was it was less than 20%, for sure. And even fewer said that they felt that they were important, in, in, in their vegetation management program, which what I’ve run into the most is we do have, you know, a few dozen utilities out there that work with us.
00:19:17:12 – 00:19:47:04
Liz
And I know there are more that do that do TGRS with other with other vendors as well. So it is gaining. It is gaining steam is gaining popularity, especially as folks are having a chance to implement it over the course of several years. And after they get past that first trial period, they’re saying, oh man, they have a hard time convincing their their higher ups that they need this, but they don’t want to get rid of it because they these foresters are seeing the results they’re getting and how less frequently they’re having to go back and send crews to those trees.
00:19:47:06 – 00:20:06:02
Liz
So slowly but surely, I think the tide is changing. It’s just about making that business case and demonstrating to the decision makers with the budget that this is a good decision. It is a good investment for the future. But it can be a hard pill to swallow because you’re going to have a higher initial cost the first year that you start using the using the service.
00:20:06:04 – 00:20:13:15
Liz
And that that’ll it’ll take, you know, a couple of years before you start seeing those returns. Yeah. As with all good practices, right.
00:20:13:17 – 00:20:30:08
Phil
Yeah. The the fairy dust idea may come from, the legacy. Get it? They used to be very inconsistent. Control. Yeah. So, yeah. Control 90% of the crown. But who cares? Because it only takes one branch following on the lines to cause a problem.
00:20:30:10 – 00:20:48:02
Liz
Yep. And so I’ll, I’ll still see that sometimes. One of the other tricks about, about TGRs is once you cut the branch after it’s after you do the treatment. Few months later, you’ll cut out any of the product that’s in that branch. Tip so many of the pack leaches, all that’s in that branch tip, is gone.
00:20:48:02 – 00:21:06:23
Liz
And, that particular branch is free to sprout. So I have seen one of my favorite pictures is, you know, imagine someone doing the rock on cymbal, right? With the two fingers up. It’s a tree that’s got a shelf cut to it, and it’s just got two branches sticking up. And, the homeowner had admitted to coming back and trimming those two branches.
00:21:06:23 – 00:21:10:06
Liz
And it’s like, yeah, I can see that.
00:21:10:08 – 00:21:38:14
Brian
Yeah, yeah. So in that space, that’s a good point. There’s a couple different things I want to follow up on. I think that to your point, since that study that came out like ten years ago, things are saying things have changed drastically in the utility space. And I would say, especially within the last few years, with the new buzzword of resiliency, affordability, grid modernization, a lot of things are coming into play, and their vegetation management has really shifted from this ancillary large budget item that we go and cyclically prune trees and removal.
00:21:38:18 – 00:22:01:17
Brian
Whatever the case may be, we’re looking at the industry very differently now. What can we use for remote sensing, advanced technologies, advanced equipment, specialized equipment, etc.? And tree growth regulators being in one of those sales to offset the challenges that we’ve historically faced. If you look at the outage, statistics and data, most of the outages that are caused is from tree related issues.
00:22:01:17 – 00:22:28:06
Brian
Right? So focusing in on it is changing. And I think the Tigers are going to have a more common place within the market space in the next 5 to 10 years. Because of that. One of the things that a follow up on in your comments, you’re talking about customer engagement, FDA approval, etc. have you noticed, pushback, public perception with chemical applications and controlled substances in the space has been negative because of some of the issues we’ve seen with some of the big players in the space.
00:22:28:06 – 00:22:37:08
Brian
But how have you overcome some of those challenges with just public perception, executive perception of the safety long term of of this product?
00:22:37:10 – 00:23:05:00
Liz
Yeah, absolutely. I think that’s the great question. And we do run into that. So we typically will run programs as opt out programs, as we call them. So with the, with our utility partners, we’ll go out and we’ll do a notification process where we’re both doing the work planning and selecting the trees. But also having those conversations with the property owners, or leaving, a door card or something behind, where they can get some information and call us about them.
00:23:05:02 – 00:23:23:21
Liz
We have a lot of these conversations with these property owners, and there are a lot who are chemically averse. They’re they don’t trust utilities in general. They don’t trust chemicals at all. And what we find is most folks, if we have a chance to actually have a conversation with them, either face to face or over the phone, a lot of them, they’re like, okay, I can see this.
00:23:23:21 – 00:23:36:22
Liz
We explain some of the benefits they’re going to see to the health of the tree. And we explain, like the real point of this and why the utility is paying for it is it’s going to reduce how frequently they have to come back and trim this tree. And that’s a big selling point to for a lot of homeowners.
00:23:36:22 – 00:23:38:08
Liz
And they care.
00:23:38:08 – 00:23:39:02
Brian
About the privacy.
00:23:39:05 – 00:23:54:16
Liz
Exactly, exactly. They don’t want they don’t want the crews on their their land is often and there are always going to be some who, no matter what you tell them, they’re just they’re against it and they don’t want to do it and they opt out. That’s fine. That’s their right. Sometimes the utility will instead give them a choice.
00:23:54:16 – 00:24:14:10
Liz
It’s like, well, we can do the TGRs or we can remove the tree? And that changes their mind pretty fast. Yeah. But we rarely see more than somewhere between 3 and 5% of folks opt out. Most people are totally cool with the treatment, even in, like, very, I will say, environmentally friendly parts of the country.
00:24:14:10 – 00:24:18:23
Liz
Right? You can probably think of a few cities off the top of your head. I am talking about those cities.
00:24:19:01 – 00:24:20:04
Brian
Yeah.
00:24:20:06 – 00:24:25:01
Liz
There’s maybe maybe 5% there, but still not as many as you might expect.
00:24:25:03 – 00:24:33:03
Brian
Yeah. That’s interesting. Yeah, yeah, I think that that perception is going to change once we start getting more data. More long term data on the application. Yeah.
00:24:33:05 – 00:24:50:15
Liz
And there have been some studies to, State of California has done a really good environmental review on paclobutrazol, all especially with regards to soil mobility. And when you’re doing soil injections, since these products, the molecule itself is, is ionized, it’ll, it’ll grip right to any, any soil that has.
00:24:50:17 – 00:24:53:17
Brian
And yeah, it’s low soil mobility which is was great.
00:24:53:19 – 00:25:11:11
Liz
So it’s not going to it’s not going to just, you know, drift away and end up in a nearby waterway. Massachusetts state of Massachusetts also did a good study, on with regards to pollinators, and shows that it has no real effect on pollinators unless you literally, like, dump the product on the bee, which.
00:25:11:13 – 00:25:12:08
Brian
Put water on a bee.
00:25:12:08 – 00:25:26:19
Liz
It’s probably pretty much right, but it’s not something that’s going to show up in the pollen. And having or in the flowers or anything and have a negative impact on those pollinators. So we’re also able to point to these studies with the folks who really want to get into it. And with, you know, higher ups at utilities who have these concerns.
00:25:26:19 – 00:25:32:17
Liz
And again, just sharing the data that’s out there has done a really good job of helping people gain more understanding about it.
00:25:32:18 – 00:25:49:04
Brian
Now, one thing about the flowers, real quick, before I forget about the things I found fascinating, is that if if there was a flower beds within the drip line or the base of the tree where you locate, you get miniature flowers, you use your plants almost like, organic bonsai. It is an.
00:25:49:06 – 00:26:08:13
Liz
I’ve seen that it’s actually kind of adorable, but they’re brighter color generally. Right. I’ve seen this. A bed of tulips around a tree, and it’s really just in that application area. So just imagine like a foot outside the, the, the flower, just that inner ring of flowers is much smaller. And then from out there they’re fine again.
00:26:08:17 – 00:26:25:14
Liz
And it’s only really the, the bulb once. It takes, you know, I say it takes the growing season to really start seeing the effects of backlit features. Also, if you’ve got your annuals, it’s not going to show up in them. But those those perennials. Yeah, we’ll see that. And it can be kind of cute. And there’s probably more them
00:26:25:16 – 00:26:30:18
Brian
Roughly 3 to 4 years is how long the product is viable within the within the industry.
00:26:30:20 – 00:26:31:10
Liz
Absolutely.
00:26:31:16 – 00:26:59:19
Brian
And then that space to, with paclobutrazol and utilizing it for free growth, regular etc.. From a viability standpoint, you mentioned earlier, I want to make sure that the audience here, this is it. If you trim it mid-stream, right, then that loses its functionality. So I’m assuming the best practice is to retreat before trim next time, evaluate, but retreat within that window so you can continue to carry on that that cellular elongation control.
00:26:59:21 – 00:27:05:10
Brian
Correct. Maximize your cycle length. So this would replace the trimming cost and cycle period.
00:27:05:12 – 00:27:20:16
Liz
It can. Absolutely. So it’s it’s tree to tree right. So I don’t want anybody to hear that and think oh I can skip, you know an entire every trees the entire all tree on my system. Exactly. Right. So it is tree by tree. And that’s why we do this with some of our, with some of our utility partners as well.
00:27:20:16 – 00:27:38:00
Liz
Right. So at that three year mark where the product is starting to wear out in the tree, you know, we’ll go back and we’ll be out there usually at the same time as the other work planners who are assessing the trees for pruning and knowing the growth rates of the tree and seeing how well regulated it was, can make a decision like retreat this.
00:27:38:01 – 00:27:53:06
Liz
So there are a lot of trees that can just get away with being only retreated and not trimmed again, and they can make it a full six plus years before they actually need to be trimmed again. Others will still need trimming after and there’s some is a really, really fast growing species around some of your cottonwoods and whatnot.
00:27:53:08 – 00:28:01:11
Liz
But again, you can trim and retreat and do do both at the same time, and at least you’re not doing as much, you know. Yeah, mid-cycle work on those reactive work.
00:28:01:13 – 00:28:03:00
Brian
Now this is a sorry Phil, I.
00:28:03:05 – 00:28:03:16
Phil
Know the guy.
00:28:03:16 – 00:28:05:03
Brian
Who’s really passionate about this, but no.
00:28:05:03 – 00:28:05:16
Liz
I love this.
00:28:05:22 – 00:28:19:17
Brian
What what trees does it work on? Deciduous. Evergreen. And then yeah, let’s get into the monocots because that’s another big topic. Yes. The columns and bamboo and the liars.
00:28:19:17 – 00:28:38:00
Liz
The not trees. Yes. All right. So we’re going to have to, first of all, to define what we mean by work, what when it says we work on those growth. There we go. Well. And it works on all of them. Technically. Technically, no. Slows growth. I’d add to that slows growth to the to the effect that you’re actually going to see a benefit.
00:28:38:00 – 00:28:55:15
Liz
Right. You’re going to see a cost benefit. You’re not gonna have to come back on that tree, as frequently as you would otherwise. Right. So the bread and butter is going to be, you know, your deciduous trees, and your most of these ones, just the way they’re, they’re growing cycle throughout the year works, and the product works really, really well on them.
00:28:55:17 – 00:29:26:10
Liz
It can work on conifers. Right. So when we’re out on especially, you know, West Coast and some of those southern areas, we absolutely do treat conifers in in California in particular, people love to plant redwoods underneath the power lines. Tallest growing species in the world. Sounds like a great choice to me. Right under the power lines and for conifers, topped ones in particular, we will see growth reduction.
00:29:26:12 – 00:29:51:13
Liz
It requires it’s always the highest rate. Whatever label you’re using, it’s going to be the highest rate category. And even then, you’re, you’re going to be lucky to get them from an annual prune to, you know, maybe two years at that point, they’re still going to come back pretty fast. So the reason we generally avoid conifers, except in some of those, like, really dramatic areas, is because they put all of their growth effort into that one single stem right there.
00:29:51:13 – 00:30:17:03
Liz
They’re very current species, and the amount of product it takes to actually get any reregulation on that is, is huge and also not legal, because we can’t go above the rates that the EPA lets us. Yeah. So, so we can get some regulation on those. But for most utilities, especially those who aren’t in, you know, very warm, very warm climate to the very long growing seasons, you’re not going to see the benefits on conifers that you’re going to see on your deciduous trees.
00:30:17:03 – 00:30:37:07
Liz
So again, it’s about scope development at that point. Some of the other ones, like we’ll do like some of the cypress trees, Leyland cypress as well as like Boulder Pond or whatnot. Again, only if they’re topped in there right into the line. But those are few and far between. So the growth habit is what matters with the deciduous versus the conifers.
00:30:37:09 – 00:30:56:22
Liz
That’s that’s kind of what we make where we make that recommendation. The monocots. Man, I know I wish it works better on bamboo. Really, I do so they there are some labels paclobutrazol out there that are meant for use on monocots. There’s a lot of turf labels out there that golf courses and turf farms and such use.
00:30:57:00 – 00:31:20:01
Liz
The had to use a lower rate form because they’re more sensitive to it, but also with the trees. And if you can’t see me, I’m doing air quotes around trees. When I talk about palms, it just doesn’t get the results you’d be looking for to slow them down before they actually get up to the line. Just the way that the growth habit of those trees work, the product isn’t as effective at slowing down that that upward growth.
00:31:20:03 – 00:31:39:21
Liz
So we don’t ever recommend really using the like our the soil injection methods on palms. I just say don’t plant them near their power lines or remove them if you can. And then you’re nodding because you totally agree with me on that one. Same with bamboo. It’s just it hasn’t it hasn’t shown to be effective. Certainly not with the methods we’re using.
00:31:40:00 – 00:31:46:23
Liz
More research required. I’d love to get into it to some more, but not not something we see used an awful lot in the industry this time.
00:31:47:00 – 00:31:55:02
Phil
So unless you started off in the field as a technician, I guess you seem to be an educator and it feels like it’s a good fit for you.
00:31:55:04 – 00:31:55:17
Liz
I love it,
00:31:55:22 – 00:31:58:14
Phil
yeah, well, I can tell that that comes through.
00:31:58:16 – 00:32:12:10
Liz
Well, I mean, that’s that’s how I got my start. There is, is was as an, as a technician in the field. Our technicians are kind of all in one. They go out and they do the work planning and the tree selection. They have the conversations with the homeowners. And then they go back and do the application.
00:32:12:10 – 00:32:34:04
Liz
And the conversations were by far some of my favorites, being able to talk about the trees and what we’re doing for them was such a, such a fun time. And also some of the other conversations you get with homeowners, and some of the crazy things they say if you’re not heard my talk on aggressive homeowners and interacting with them, I’ve got I’ve got some fun stories from the years on that.
00:32:34:06 – 00:32:38:21
Phil
Well, so we’re going to have to have you back and listen to stories.
00:32:38:23 – 00:32:41:09
Liz
Fair enough. Hey, I’ll come back. No worries there.
00:32:41:11 – 00:32:49:05
Phil
Well, this has been a lot of fun. It really has been interesting. I have a feeling that our listeners are thinking, there’s three tree nerds.
00:32:49:06 – 00:32:50:17
Liz
I think so.
00:32:50:18 – 00:32:59:03
Phil
But that’s okay. Thanks for joining us today. Follow us on LinkedIn for updates. And to tune in again to the Trees and Lines podcast.